What to Do When Your Broker Sells Your Account to a Rival

UK traders at one of the country’s longest-running retail brokers will change firms this month without signing up for another. FXCM’s UK accounts will close shortly after 10pm on Friday 20 November, and new Trade Nation accounts will go live when markets open on Sunday 22 November, after Stratos Markets, which runs FXCM in Britain, agreed to sell its UK client book in October. Accounts that have been inactive may move earlier, in the week starting 16 November.

But this is one deal in a much bigger wave. AvaTrade has agreed to buy the majority of FXCM’s remaining business, and Capital.com has agreed to take on FxPro’s European client book, all within the same few weeks. The terms vary from deal to deal. Capital.com’s transfer still depends on approval from CySEC and on whether individual clients are eligible, while the FXCM move takes everyone who doesn’t opt out. Either way, the clients move with the balances, usually whether they asked to or not.

- Advertisement -

If one of these letters has already landed in your inbox, or lands in it next year, the details will matter more than they first appear. So let’s get into what actually moves in a client book sale, what gets closed on your behalf, and how to decide whether the new firm deserves to keep your money.

Why Open Positions Get Closed Before the Move

A client book sale covers your account, your cash balance and your personal details. Live trades stay behind. The two firms run different pricing and different systems, so open positions usually can’t be lifted across, and the selling broker closes them before the money moves.

That’s exactly how the FXCM transfer works. Open positions will be closed by FXCM at the close of business on 20 November, the cash will then move across, and the new Trade Nation account goes live when markets open on Sunday night. Trade Nation will send log-in details over the weekend, and at the first sign-in you’ll set a password and accept the new terms before you can trade. Anyone who ignores the letters will have their trades closed at whatever the market price happens to be that Friday.

The tax side deserves some attention too. Spread betting profits typically fall outside capital gains tax in the UK, so a forced closure usually changes nothing there. Closing a CFD position, on the other hand, typically counts as a disposal for capital gains tax, which means a transfer can crystallise gains or losses in the current tax year whether you planned to or not. For 2026/27 the annual exempt amount will be £3,000, with anything above it charged at 18% or 24% depending on your income, so a closure you didn’t choose can push you past a threshold you were managing around. If you hold large unrealised CFD positions, speak to a tax adviser before the date rather than after it.

- Advertisement -

Treat the New Broker as a Fresh Decision

The firm you inherit might suit you perfectly well. Trade Nation holds FCA authorisation, client money stays in segregated accounts with Tier 1 UK banks throughout the FXCM move, and eligible claims against a failed investment firm are covered by the FSCS up to £85,000.

Even so, the terms you traded on will change. Spreads, overnight financing and pricing models differ between firms, and spread bettors who size trades in contracts and lots at FXCM will be choosing an amount per point at Trade Nation instead. MT4 CFD accounts will stay on MT4 and TradingView users will reconnect their charts, but Trading Station II accounts and MT4 spread bet accounts will all move onto TN Trader, Trade Nation’s own platform.

James Warwick, former FTSE 100 Director and founder of Trading Brokers, the popular broker comparison site, told us “A broker you’ve been handed should pass the same tests as a broker you’d pick yourself. Start by confirming its FCA authorisation on the register, because that’s the foundation for everything else. Then look hard at the fees, since it’s very unlikely that the spreads and charges will match your old firm’s. Even small differences here will compound trade after trade. Spend time on the platform before you commit real money through it as well, because usability shapes every decision you’ll make on it. If the firm doesn’t hold up under that scrutiny, you’re free to take your balance somewhere that does.”

Warwick also points out that inertia tends to be the expensive option here, since clients who drift into a new firm rarely go back and check how its costs compare with what they were paying before.

Don’t Stall Because Opt-Out Windows Close Fast

FXCM’s UK clients were emailed their options on 6 October and had until 5 November to say no. That’s a window of one month, which is easy to lose to a full inbox. These windows are short by design, because both firms want a clean migration with a fixed completion date.

Withdrawing your money doesn’t count as opting out, either. In the FXCM process, clients who want out have to complete a separate opt-out form, otherwise an account still gets opened for them at the new firm. That window shut on 5 November, so FXCM clients who didn’t file the form will get a Trade Nation account whether they want one or not, even if they close their positions and empty the balance first. Anyone who thinks their account is closing in error should speak to FXCM’s client services team, though neither firm will promise a late change.

Five Moves to Make Before the Transfer Date

A transfer letter comes with its own to-do list, even if you end up accepting the move. These five will cover most situations:

  1. Read the timetable against a calendar. Note the opt-out deadline, the closure date and the day the new account goes live, because each date removes an option once it passes.
  2. Deal with open positions yourself. Closing or re-entering on your own schedule beats letting a forced closure pick the price, and the tax year, for you.
  3. Download your statements. Once the old login disappears, so will easy access to your trade history, and HMRC can ask about past tax years long after the broker has gone.
  4. Cost the new firm out properly. Compare its spreads, charges and platform against your old costs and the wider market, then either accept the transfer or withdraw and open an account somewhere you’ve actually chosen.
  5. If the opt-out deadline has gone, decide anyway. FXCM’s closed on 5 November, so the account will open at Trade Nation either way. You can still close positions and withdraw your balance before your own transfer date, which is 20 November for most clients and as early as the week starting 16 November if the account has been inactive. After that, the money will be there to withdraw from the new account. A missed form won’t lock your money in.

More of These Letters Are Coming

Consolidation among CFD and spread betting firms has gained pace in recent years, and the FXCM carve-up certainly won’t be the last deal of its kind. Client books are valuable to buyers and costly for smaller firms to keep serving, so the letters will keep arriving.

The habit to build is treating each one as a decision with a deadline instead of a piece of admin. The traders who come out of these transfers well will be the ones who read the letter twice, note the dates and make the choice themselves before the default makes it for them.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information only and isn’t financial or tax advice. Speak to a qualified adviser about your own circumstances before acting on a broker transfer.

Latest News

More Articles Like This